Confused? Lemme clear things up. That game sucked becasue:

1. It completely ruined the story of FF X-2.
2. Turned the innocent Rikku and the calm and quiet priestess Yuna into two super extroverted sluts.
3. For the first time in the Final Fantasy history, the music sucked (a few tracks are exceptions).
4. The newly introduced characters were just stupid.
5. The story had no twists at all and was completely pointless.
6. The new Blitzball game sucked.
7. The voiceovers and the scenes were completely out of sync (in the English version, at least).
8. Too short for an RPG game.

On the positive side, the movies were still as crsip and beautiful as ever and the battle system wasn't that bad.

I don't say the game is crap itself, but considering that it was a sequel to one of the greatest games ever made, we (the fans) expected more than just dressing up girls and hunting some weird video recording orbs or spheres or whatever they are called.